//
you're reading...
Essay's, Journalism Law

Public No More: The Jesse Ventura Defamation Case

Public No More: The Jesse Ventura Defamation Case


The United States libel and defamation laws can be traced in our history to the era prior to the American Revolution.

Technologies have changed our communication habits which has opened a 24/7 platform, allowing everyone and anyone with broader capabilities to express themselves, their ideas and their stories.

jesse ventura

Image: Washington Post

 


Chris Kyle is one of those people who, like many others in our digital era, wrote a memoir about his life. He was a highly decorated Navy SEAL that completed four tours in Iraq between the years of 1999-2009.  The former Navy SEAL has been regarded as the deadliest sniper U.S. military history.

In his book “American Sniper,” he wrote a sub-chapter called “Punching Out Scruff Face” in which he describes punching Jesse Ventura at a California bar in 2006 (Davey, 2014).


The incident was said to have happened after Ventura allegedly made offensive comments about the Navy SEAL’s.  Kyle (2006) quoted Venture allegedly saying- “the SEAL’s deserve to lose a few in Iraq.”

 Jesse Ventura a Navy SEAL himself, serving in the 1970’s claims he would never speak of the Military in that way and that he never had an altercation with Kyle at the bar.

The 1964 case New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, has been a critical ruling, setting an important precedent for libel cases involving public figures.

In the landmark case New York Times Co. v. Sullivan  “proof of actual malice” is required for an award of damages in an action for libel involving public figures or matters of public concern.


american sniper book

Image: The Hollywood Reporter

After publication of Chris Kyle’s book,  Venture filed suit claiming Kyle had defamed him in the sub-chapter, even though Kyle did not specifically name Ventura in his book.

 

Libel law probably goes furthest in protecting people in their business and occupations. Today,  libel law and laws protecting people against defamation have become complex and often considers and applies the protections within the First Amendment for cases dealing with defamation or libel.

Identification is very important in a defamation case and Pember and Calvert (2013) explain, the injured party must show the court that the alleged defamatory statement is… “of and concerning him, her, or it.” 

Kyle’s remarks were found to be libelous and Ventura was awarded 1.8 million dollars for -unjust enrichment.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit ruled in 1980 that an identification might be established if…

“a reasonable reader rationally suspects that the protagonist is in fact the plaintiff, notwithstanding the author’s and publisher’s assurances that the work is fiction” (Pember &Calvert, 2013) 

With each evolving century the American judiciary system has reinterpreted defamation and libel laws, ensuring constitutional rights are still protected.  Our new and modern digitized world will continue to shift, changing the societal norms and bringing into question new issues regarding defamation and libel laws.


References & Citation List

 

 

About K. Ryan

My name is Krysta Ryan and I am a student at Ashford University seeking a bachelor's degree in Journalism and a bachelor's degree Mass Communication. I am from Cincinnati Ohio in which my professional experiences include Executive Management within the nonprofit sector and worked as a Social Media Manager which allowed me to gain a working knowledge of writing for newer digital platforms.

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Journalistic-ly on WordPress.com

Journalistic Ideology

Music, Sensor Trigger

Ironically, the power of music is rarely discussed as a medium to share messages, but it is very powerful in influencing human behavior and aids in critical thinking. The arrangement of musical sounds, depending on intensity, the music alone can trigger sensories, to cause a human response. In other words,  musical sounds provide a rhythm […]

Why storms are named after people?

Do not fall in love with people like me. I will take you to museums, and parks, and monuments, and kiss you in every beautiful place, so that you can never go back to them without tasting me like blood in your mouth. I will destroy you in the most beautiful way possible. And when […]

Local Cincinnati School Allows Digital Devices in Classroom

Cincinnati School District creates a Bring Your Own Device Policy or BYOD.

Quote

Author Qualifications

  • Bachelor’s in Journalism
  • Bachelor’s Mass Communication
  • Minor in Writing
  • Specialization
    • Environmental Science
%d bloggers like this: